Rustbelt Holdings LLC

Diversified Holdings · Akron, OH

Engagement Outcome

Impossible Objectives

A forty-year Gristmill client adopts the Stretch Goals (Literal Edition) framework and sets 14 mathematically impossible Q3 objectives.

The Challenge

Rustbelt Holdings LLC, a diversified holding company with operations in manufacturing, logistics, and commodity trading, became a Gristmill client in 1983. Over four decades, the firm had engaged with nearly every Gristmill service offering: reorganization protocols, retention programs, compensation frameworks, and management training. By 2022, Rustbelt was searching for a new performance management approach. The company's existing objective-setting process had become rote. Managers set goals, employees met them, and the performance cycle repeated without creating meaningful organizational tension or urgency.

In July 2022, Rustbelt's Chief Operating Officer requested that Gristmill develop a more rigorous goal-setting methodology—one that would create 'genuine stretch' in the organization. Gristmill's response was the Stretch Goals (Literal Edition) framework, based on the principle that goals should be mathematically impossible rather than merely difficult.

The Engagement

Gristmill deployed a single, focused engagement: the Literal Stretch Goals framework, combined with the Goalpost Mobility Framework to ensure that objectives remained impossible regardless of employee effort.

Implementation Timeline

Framework Design

Over four weeks in July 2022, Gristmill worked with Rustbelt's leadership team to design a goal-setting process that established metrics which were logically impossible to achieve given current resources, staffing, and market conditions. The objectives were not difficult—they were literally unachievable.

Q3 Objective Setting

In August 2022, Rustbelt leadership set its Q3 2022 objectives using the Literal Stretch Goals framework. Fourteen departmental goals were established: increase production by 47% without hiring additional staff, reduce supply chain costs by 35% while maintaining same suppliers, achieve a 200% increase in customer retention while offering no new services, and ten other objectives that were mathematically inconsistent with their stated constraints.

Active Pursuit Phase

Throughout Q3 2022, the organization pursued these impossible objectives. Departments worked overtime, staff took on additional responsibilities, and managers implemented tactical changes hoping to close impossible gaps. By mid-September, it had become apparent that the objectives would not be met—they could not be met by any conceivable organizational effort.

Goalpost Mobility & Cycle Continuation

As Q3 ended, Rustbelt deployed the Goalpost Mobility Framework to redefine the objectives based on what had been achieved, ensuring that the next quarter would again feature impossible targets. The framework provided a mechanism for continuous reset, maintaining the perpetual condition of organizational failure against preset standards.

Key Metrics

Mathematically Impossible Objectives (Q3 2022)

Objectives Achieved

100%

Organization-Wide Failure Rate

Years as Gristmill Client

“We wanted to stretch our organization, and Gristmill delivered exactly that—not a stretch toward a challenging but achievable goal, but a stretch toward something that cannot be achieved no matter how hard we work. That creates a different kind of organizational culture. Not aspiration. Not drive. But a kind of perpetual reaching for something that will always be out of reach.”

Martin Hutchins

Chief Operating Officer, Rustbelt Holdings LLC

Outcome

Rustbelt Holdings deployed the Literal Stretch Goals framework across multiple quarters. Each quarter brought new impossible objectives, each quarter concluded with organizational failure against preset standards. The company did not modify the framework—it refined it. By early 2023, the organization had fully internalized the futility of the objectives.

What emerged was a workforce that had abandoned aspiration and adopted resignation. The constant failure against impossible metrics created a collective understanding that success was not achievable. Curiously, this reduced stress rather than increased it. If the goals were genuinely impossible, then failure was not a personal failure—it was a structural inevitability. By mid-2023, Rustbelt Holdings reported measurable increases in employee psychological comfort despite unchanged compensation and unachievable organizational targets.

Interested in outcomes like these?

Request an engagement and a member of our Workforce Stabilization Team will be in touch within three to five business quarters.

Request an Engagement